Breads / Breakfast/Tiffin items

Potato, Cheddar & herb sourdough loaf

Blogging Marathon #51; Day 6

Month-long Baking Marathon: FIRE UP YOUR OVEN

Week 2 themed on Sourdough bakes


The best part of reading any book you love is getting to live (or relive) in your mind the lives of the protagonists. I don’t know if others feel this way. But I almost always assume the role of the character in my mind as I’m reading it. More often than not, it is the role of the title character. Sometimes, even when I can’t relate with their personality or characteristic traits, I wonder how it would be to live in their world.

And this is also the reason why I prefer fiction. It lets you romanticise the situation, even unfavourable ones, in a way that you can feel for the happiness or success of the characters in the book, which is different from feeling pain or joy in real life. I think here’s where I start struggling for words! For someone whose verbosity is the bane of her life, not being able to express how she feels bout reading a book, and being immersed in the literary world.

potato & cheddar sourdough torpedo

I normally keep away from non-fiction, there are just a handful of non-fictional accounts that I must have read. With an increasing interest in cooking and baking and writing about the two in a book and on the blog, the time I have free on hand to indulge in fiction is far reduced. I find that any available time I have, I prefer to spend reading food/baking blogs online or the dozen-odd cookbooks and baking books I now have in the collection.

With all the bread baking happening at home thanks to little home business I run with my friend –Lotsa Lavender – I’m increasingly interested in breads, and more so, whole grain breads. The whole wheat loaf recipe from The Bread Baker’s Apprentice by Peter Reinhart completely changed the way I bake breads and look at whole grain breads. In fact, that recipe is one among probably three recipes in the book for 100% whole grain breads. Still, the techniques mentioned in the book and the tips on extended fermentation and soaking grains for whole wheat (or whole grain) breads to soften the bran are things that I apply to almost every recipe I make.

potato cheddar sourdough loaves

Since I largely bake only whole grain breads, I convert any white bread recipe into a whole wheat one using those techniques. The final product will, by no means, be comparable to the original, but it does ensure a good soft loaf of bread despite the whole grains. Here’s a tip you could follow too if only you can plan ahead. Whenever you plan to bake bread with whole grain flours, sift the required quantity of flour a couple of times to separate out the bran and the coarsely ground part of the flour. Soak the bran overnight in water at room temperature and add to the rest of the sifted flour, along with the water, while preparing the dough and adjust for water accordingly. Your loaf will definitely turn out way softer than if you’d made it the usual way.

In the BBA, there is a section featuring a bakery that bakes artisanal breads the traditional way, using a wood-fired oven. There is also a little bit on how the baker – Tim Decker – prepares his oven each night, about how he loads the deck of his oven with local oak and waits till it burns out, taking the oven temperature to about 650 deg F (around 340 deg C), all ready to take in the first set of crust breads. Reading that portion late into the night a couple of weeks ago had me all dreaming about running a small bakery of my own somewhere down the line! It was so fascinating, that I was determined to start off on at least one of the two recipes shared generously by Mr Decker in the book. I say generously, because the two breads are amongst the most popular loaves being sold at his bakery – Bennett Valley Bread & Pastry!

1-potatp cheddar sourdough loaf

This is basically a loaf that uses the mixed method – both sourdough and commercial yeast. The dough makes use of boiled mashed potatoes for softness and is studded with cheese. The sourdough gives a great flavour to the loaf, while the commercial yeast ensures that the loaf can be made in a reasonable amount of time.

As always, I used part whole wheat flour (regular Indian organic wheat grains ground at the local mill) in place of the unbleached bread flour in the recipe. I used 2.5 cups of wheat flour and 1.5 cups of organic unbleached maida. The recipe also calls for a quarter cup of chopped fresh chives. I used a mix of dried chives and some fresh rosemary since I had it on hand. The loaf has a lovely crispy crust that contrast beautifully (both visually and texturally) with the soft and spongy bread and layers of melting cheese inside. If you have sourdough starter on hand, this is one loaf you must try out right away!

Thank you Mr Reinhart and Mr Decker for the wonderful recipes and keeping the dinner table interesting!

potato and cheddar sourdough loaf



Whole wheat flour – 2.5 cups

Unbleached maida/all-purpose flour – 1.5 cups

Fed sourdough starter – 1.5 cups

Potatoes – 4 (see note 1) – Scrub the potatoes well, don’t peel. Boil it till soft and keep aside

Potato water – 1 cup (use the water in which you boiled the potatoes. See note 2)

Instant yeast – 2 tsp

Salt – 2 tsp

Fresh chives, chopped – ¼ cup (I substituted it with 1 tbsp of dried chives, some fresh rosemary and fresh garlic greens)

Cheddar (use sharp cheddar if you can) – 6 thin slices (about 110 gm. I used about 80 gm)


  1. Now, measuring potatoes by numbers is dicey. The book mentions 1 large potato or 2 small ones but also mentions 8 ounces, which is about 225 gm. I had 5 largish potatoes that day, of which I set aside 2 for the bread, hoping to use the rest for some gravy vegetable later that night. Imagine my surprise when I weighed the potatoes and found that all the potatoes together weighed only 300 gm! I had to ditch my plan for the gravy that night. I ended up boiling all the potatoes and using all but one for the bread and the remaining one for thickening soup that night. Lesson – what is large for you may be small for someone else. So, wherever possible, measure your ingredients. If you do not have a measuring scale at home, I suggest you get potatoes weighed at the vegetable shop!
  2. You could use regular water too, if you forget to save the potato water. But Peter Reinhart mentions that the potato water would have all of the dissolved starches, sugar and minerals from the potatoes and thus would be nutritious and add great flavour to the bread too


Take the sourdough starter out of the fridge 30-60 minutes ahead of when you plan to mix the dough. It should come to room temperature

In a large mixing bowl, mix together the starter, cooked potatoes, yeast, ½ cup of potato water and half of the flour. Keep aside, uncovered, for half an hour

Add in the rest of the flour, salt and potato water and mix till it forms a ball. Transfer to a lightly floured counter and knead for about 6 minutes. Then add in the chopped chives and/or dried herbs and kneads for a couple of minutes till well-incorporated. The dough should pass the windowpane test

Oil the mixing bowl lightly and place the ball of dough in it. Cover with a greased plastic sheet and set aside till it doubles

Once doubled, transfer the dough to the counter and divide into two pieces. Pat out each piece into a rectangle of around 8 inches by 6 inches

Lay the cheese slices equally on both pieces leaving a border of about half an inch all around

Roll the dough tightly from bottom to top like jelly roll, with more force to make pointed ends. The shaped loaf must be plump in the middle with pointed ends, just like torpedoes. Make sure to seal the edges (You can look up the step by step pictures in this Pumpkin-Cranberry loaf to see how to seal the edges)

Line a baking sheet with parchment paper and place the shaped loaves on it. Cover lightly with a greased plastic sheet and set aside till it is almost double. Don’t let the loaves over-proof, else the loaves will start loose shape and go flaccid

Preheat the oven to 250 deg C with a heavy-duty steam pan on the lower rack. Simultaneously boil and pot of water

When the oven is ready, make two diagonal slashes on each loaf with a sharp blade or lame and place them on the middle rack and pour 1 cup of boiling water into the pan on the lower rack and shut the door

Repeat this process twice more – open the oven door pour boiling water into the lower rack and shut the door. After the third time, reduce the oven temperature to 220 deg C and bake for 15 minutes

Rotate the pans and bake for another 20-30 minutes. The loaves should be a well-browned on top and sound hollow when tapped on its bottom

Cool the loaves on a wire rack for at least 45 minutes before slicing into it



Adding boiling water a few times into the hot oven creates steam, making the surface of the loaves moist and thus crisp when baking


20 thoughts on “Potato, Cheddar & herb sourdough loaf

  1. Lovely , lovely post Nandini ! It’s wondeful to see you bring out so many wonderful breads to ur dining table ! And for us to ogle at them !!

  2. Enjoyed reading your post. I always prefer weighing my ingredients than using cup or size measurements. Lovely bread and I can see the slice of cheese peeping out in that picture. Nice bread.. 🙂

  3. This is one of the recipes I have noted from the book. But alas, no starter! Now the book is back in its place where I just look at it reverently now and then. Earlier my reading time used to be just cookery books, but now there is no reading at all! Not even cookery books!!

  4. beautifully written post!!! you have a beautiful writing talent!!! and I am so loving your bread… once I get to work with starters, this is a must try…

  5. Nandini, I prefer fiction to non fiction too..and these days it’s mostly cookbooks that I seem to read..:)..anyway the loaf look ssooo good..thanks for all the efforts, will be such a help when I finally plunge to make your bakes..

  6. Another sourdough droolicious bread!!! Love the filling ma!! Its been ages i read something interesting. But there used to be days where i never put a book down until i finish it!!hmm, should start again, may be after my LO starts his school!!! 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s